From stakeholders to algorithms: Expanding the Harvard HCM model

Stakeholders to Algorithms is the move from the old way, relying on the subjective feedback and influence of various stakeholders to a new, data-driven approach where algorithms and AI play a central role. It's taking the core principles of the Harvard HCM Model which looks at employee influence, HR flow, and organizational outcomes and supercharging them with technology. 

This blog isn't replacing people with robots. The Harvard HCM Model, with the focus on employee commitment, competence, and cost-effectiveness, remains crucial. Algorithms, on the other hand, can process massive amounts of data on things like performance, and talent acquisition, providing insights that were previously impossible or too slow to get.

The algorithmic compass: Navigating the new HR landscape 

The algorithmic compass uses data to find the cold, hard truth. An algorithm can analyze thousands of performance reviews, engagement surveys, and productivity metrics to reveal the real story. 

• Objective hiring: An algorithm can screen resumes for the specific skills that are proven to predict high performance, effectively stripping away unconscious bias from the hiring process. This moves you beyond a hiring manager's subjective whim and towards a more equitable and effective approach.
• Real-time insights: Instead of relying on a useless annual survey, real-time feedback algorithms can provide a constant pulse on employee sentiment. This helps to spot a team on the brink of burnout or identify which skills actually lead to success.
• Data-driven decisions: The algorithmic compass helps to figure out what's really working and what's not. It provides the data you need to make informed, strategic decisions, moving HR from a reactive function to a proactive one.

The key is to use these tools as a compass. The algorithms point in the right direction, but human judgment and empathy are still essential. The algorithm might tell an employee is at risk of leaving, but it's the HR manager's job to have that compassionate conversation and understand the "why" behind the data. 

Stakeholders still matter, and AI is a new partner 

The Harvard Model's focus on stakeholders is still critical, even with the rise of AI. While balancing everyone's competing interests can be challenging, technology can help HR leaders make smarter decisions without sacrificing the human touch. The key is to use AI to support the interactions with stakeholders.

Using AI to serve stakeholders

• Employees: The model emphasizes boosting commitment and competence. AI can help by personalizing the employee experience. For example, an algorithm can analyze performance data to recommend specific training courses, ensuring employees get the development they need to succeed. 
• Managers: Managers prioritize efficiency and results. AI can be their wingman, helping to predict which candidates will be a good fit for a team or identifying when a high-performer is at risk of burnout. 

The Harvard Model's strength lies in its emphasis on human interaction. Use AI to inform decisions, but always engage with stakeholders to ensure they feel heard, valued, and not overruled by a computer.

The Harvard model in a messy world 

The Harvard Model's focus on situational factors, like company culture and market trends is more relevant than ever. While this once meant worrying about union strikes, it now involves navigating the complexities of remote work, the gig economy, and the rise of AI. The Harvard Model says to adapt policies to fit the context, and AI makes this possible in a world of remote work and the gig economy.

• Remote work: Use AI to track productivity across time zones or spot disengagement in virtual teams. Off-the-shelf AI tools can analyze work patterns to suggest when an employee is overwhelmed with meetings. This is a practical application of the model in today’s remote reality.
• The gig economy: Gig workers are a new kind of stakeholder, and algorithms can help manage them by tracking performance, predicting churn, and matching skills to tasks. However, the model reminds you to blend tech with empathy. Gig workers want respect and flexibility, not just a paycheck. 

Algorithms and AI can revolutionize HR policies by replacing subjective guesswork with data-driven insights. This shift allows HR to move beyond traditional, outdated methods and make more strategic decisions that align with business and stakeholder needs.

Data-driven performance management

The Harvard Model emphasizes competence as a key outcome, but outdated tools like annual reviews fail to provide a complete picture. Algorithms offer a solution by providing real-time performance data.

• Continuous feedback: AI-powered tools can track metrics like project completion rates and customer feedback, giving managers a live pulse on who is excelling and who may need support. This makes performance management an ongoing process rather than a static, once-a-year event.
• Predictive insights: Algorithms can identify teams at risk of burnout before a manager even notices, allowing HR to intervene proactively. This helps to maintain a healthy and productive workforce.

Personalized rewards and recognition

The Harvard Model advocates for aligning rewards with stakeholder needs, which is challenging when everyone wants something different. AI solves this by crunching data to understand what truly motivates individual employees.

• Tailored Packages: Algorithms can analyze an employee's profile to suggest personalized reward packages, whether it's a cash bonus, more flexibility, or a specific type of recognition. This ensures that rewards are meaningful and effective.
• Sharpening Judgment: AI doesn't replace but it enhances human judgment. It provides HR leaders with the data to back up their decisions, making their choices more strategic and impactful. 

‍

Algorithms are not a perfect solution

Let's not pretend algorithms are all sunshine and rainbows. The Harvard Model emphasizes balance, and relying too heavily on AI can easily tip the scales. A major risk is algorithmic bias. If the data fed to an algorithm is biased, the algorithm will be, too. If the past hiring practices favored a certain demographic, the algorithm might learn to do the same, perpetuating the problem. This is a real risk and a critical responsibility for HR professionals.

• The importance of human judgment 

The Harvard Model highlights that stakeholders matter, but algorithms don't have empathy. Over-relying on them can create a dehumanized workplace where employees feel like cogs in a machine, not valued individuals. To prevent this, use AI to inform, not dictate. The model's strength is its human touch, and must protect that from being stripped away by technology.

• Blending tech with human principles 

The solution is to blend AI with the Harvard model's principles. Use data to spot patterns and uncover insights, but always let humans make the final, critical decisions. It's essential to train the team to understand and interpret AI outputs, so they can use the information to make better, more informed choices, rather than blindly following a computer's recommendations.

HR as the ethical gatekeeper

It's not enough to simply "plug and play" with new technology. HR must be the ethical gatekeeper for organization.

• Audit the data: You need to audit data for existing biases and ensure algorithms are not creating new ones.
• Question everything: Ask tough questions about data sources, the assumptions algorithms are making, and the outcomes they produce.
• Diligence, not blind trust: The move to algorithms is not a silver bullet. It's a powerful tool that requires a new level of diligence and ethical responsibility to ensure that the technology used is making the workplace more equitable. 

Wrapping it up 

The Harvard Model with algorithms, isn’t a theory, it's a call to action. An HR manager; is strategic, and can make or break the company’s future.This isn't a tech takeover, its an evolution. It's about taking the guesswork and the politics out of HR and replacing it with real, actionable insights.

The Harvard Model’s core is about people, not machines. Use algorithms to free up time for what matters: talking to employees, building culture, making the workplace not suck. The future of HR isn’t AI replacing HR, but HR using AI to be better at the job. 

‍