HR management platform
Subscribe to our Newsletter!
Thank you! You are subscribed to our blogs!
Oops! Something went wrong. Please try again.
Do you trust your gut in the hiring process? Maybe stop
Hiring and Recruitment

Do you trust your gut in the hiring process? Maybe stop

Dorothy Dalton
February 27, 2024

If I had a Euro for the times I have heard my gut feeling in hiring process say these three things, I could probably retire.

  • "It didn’t feel right."
  • "He/she wouldn’t fit"
  • "There was something about…"

Can you really trust your 'gut feeling' in recruitment?

Trusting our instincts can help us in many ways. But trusting our gut feeling in hiring can mislead us into safe, tried and tested decisions, which are not always the best. They certainly don’t lead to building diverse teams. Should you trust your gut feeling in hiring decisions?

Most of the times when you hear your gut feeling in hiring, the process turns out ineffective, either profoundly or marginally. But despite the publicity around the inefficiencies and the cost of making the wrong hiring decisions, companies rarely change their approach to filling open vacancies.

They rely on submitted applications and key worded ATS searches, (See the ROI of ATS) network referrals, telephone or video screening, maybe some psychometric testing or a behavioural interview task and finally an unstructured interview(s).

Sometimes there could be series of 5 or more interviews with different members of an organisation at different times, but frequently  covering the same ground.  Some candidates report up to 9 interviews requiring multiple vacation days on top of hours of preparation. If they are rejected some never even find out why.

There are multiple reasons for adhering to these outdated and flawed systems:

  • No one has any experience of doing anything differently. Interviewers complain about being cramped by more structured and standardized approaches which they feel are more formal and potentially intimidating to top candidates. They want candidates to like them. (See also: Text Recruiting guide on how to keep your candidates engaged.)
  • Most managers disregard the recruitment metrics to track and think they can trust their gut feeling in hiring when it comes to making the right hire, especially when it comes to building a team. Their team. They can resent the interference of outside influences – such as HR or even an external specialist.
  • Many organisations want shared responsibility for hiring. It deflects accountability if something goes wrong.

Also Read: The Truth About Applicant Tracking Systems

Yet there is overwhelming data to suggest that more consistent and formal approaches work better than casual and laissez- faire set-ups. Structured interviews are the best way to assess potential talent in a hiring process. The challenge is getting hiring managers to accept and then adopt the methodology.

One of the top recruiting challenges is daily commitments and getting all players to stop trusting their gut feeling in hiring. But if people are looked up as an asset to the business, then a thorough training program can help accommodate bias-free interviews and reduce time to hire.

gut feeling in hiring

6 ways to avoid having to rely on your gut feeling in the hiring process

1. Manage expectations

One of the most off-putting situations for any candidate is not having clarity around the process and what exactly is going to happen. If possible this should be explained upfront  before the interview with details on the hiring process. If candidates understand that the interview is set up to make sure that all candidates will be be treated fairly and equally and asked the same questions. If there is any pre-interview chat as part of the warming up process, keep it to neutral generalities. The weather and, journey to the venue are both banal and uncontentious and should be non-bias orientating discussions.

Also Refer to: 10 top hiring resources to help you hire better in 2022

2. Select a diverse panel

if possible interviewers should be as diverse as possible in terms of background, age, seniority and personality types. There clearly has to be a subject expert in the group. The rise of hybrid recruiting is a good opportunity to give junior employees exposure to the hiring process to prepare them for the future. VP roles don’t have to be interviewed exclusively by peers or more senior employees.

3. Bench mark competencies

The role should have a properly prepared job description with a clear definition of the main competences against which each candidate will be assessed on a matrix with scaled results for hard and soft skills. Questions around which skills or personality traits are missing from the team should be asked rather than looking for people who will fit in and others will “like.”

Hard skills are easy to evaluate:  For example fluency in a second language might be a necessary qualification. In which case it will be benchmarked at 9 or 10.   An engineering degree likewise. Soft skills are harder to assess and questions need to be structured so that a candidate can describe situations where they have exhibited those particular skills as part of their career stories.

Creating a score card is invaluable in guided thinking and increasing mindfulness in the recruitment process, instead of relying on your gut feeling in hiring.

4. Structure questioning

Panel members or interviewers should have a pre-determined schedule for asking questions, with a series of prepared questions. Then it should be decided who will be covering which topics and the order of questioning.

Some ways to cultivate the strategy of structure questioning is reading the insights coming from recruitment thought leaders or making use of behavioural questions are always helpful.

“Tell us about a time you had to deal with a situation when your opinion was the minority view. How did you deal with that?” You can deep-dive with more penetrating questions: “What sort of opposition did you encounter?“, “How did you follow-up?“, “What was the outcome,”

5. Be accountable

Interviewers should evaluate candidates against the benchmark matrix consistently for all candidates. This can be scaled 1-5, or 1-10 based on the profile. If a person speaks French fluently they will be allocated a 10 against the benchmark. Conversational French might be a 5.

To avoid listening to your gut feeling in hiring, it’s important to be able to discuss any divergence in evaluations between the hiring team. This is the moment to raise concerns about potential unconscious bias. Why did one interviewer give a candidate a low rating on a particular skill when others rated him or her more highly? This will be invaluable to identifying the barriers to effective decision-making.

Any discrepancies in scoring should be highlighted in relation to potential bias in the most constructive way possible. For instance, recruitment automation allows prompt decision-making and the opportunity to give measured feedback if candidates ask for it.

6. Make an immediate decision

The mind can play some strange tricks, so any discussion should be held at the end and also if necessary mid-way through the process depending on how many candidates are being interviewed. It might be important to check that everyone is on the same page. It is very common for hiring decisions to go through multiple layers of approval only to have the original decision overturned.

Leaders, in today's novel recruitment market, you have to trust your teams to hire someone you've never met in person. Micro-managing the process can be very frustrating for all involved. One of the most important revelations in any hiring process is for those involved to understand that their instincts may not always lead them down the right path. This is why unconscious bias  awareness training for everyone involved in the recruitment process is so important. So, to answer your question, "Can you really trust your 'gut feeling' in recruitment?" -

Choosing a recruitment management system can help organisations make systemic changes to their recruitment processes to produce better results both for the business and candidates. And no one likes change. That’s the problem.

See our award-winning HR Software in action
Book a demo
Schedule a demo
Is accurate payroll processing a challenge? Find out how peopleHum can assist you!
Book a demo
Book a demo
See our award-winning HR Software in action
Schedule a demo

See our award-winning HR Software in action

Schedule a demo
Blogs related to "
Do you trust your gut in the hiring process? Maybe stop

Schedule a Demo !

Get a personalized demo with our experts to get you started
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text
This is some text inside of a div block.
Thank you for scheduling a demo with us! Please check your email inbox for further details.
Explore payroll
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Contact Us!
Get a personalized demo with our experts to get you started
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
This is some text inside of a div block.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.